CORONAVIRUS: UNIVERSITY RETURN 'COULD SPARK COVID AVALANCHE'
On Sunday 30 August 2020, BBC News Education and Social Affairs Reporter, Hannah Richardson, posted that the leader of the University and College Lecturers Union (UCU) and the President of the National Union of Students have agreed about the risks from Covid-19 as tens of thousands of students return to towns and cities across the UK for the beginning of the Autumn university term.
Editor's Note: The BBC News report has been updated since it was first uploaded to this website. As a result, this page has also been updated. The older posting by Hannah Richardson has been retained and remains of interest. It follows on from the updated article.
Universities in the UK are being urged to scrap plans for face-to-face teaching until Christmas in order to prevent a second wave of coronavirus
Academics' union UCU said more than a million students moving around the country was "a recipe for disaster".
But university bosses say they have worked hard to plan for a safe return to all aspects of student life.
It comes as daily recorded cases of coronavirus in the UK reached 1,715 in 24 hours, the highest since early June.
Case numbers began edging up again in the UK in July, after falling in June - but are still much lower than the 5,000 new cases a day there were in April, at the peak of the epidemic.
Experts say the increase in testing over recent weeks means more people with the virus are being detected.
What's the union saying?
The UCU's Jo Grady says having tens of thousands of students heading into cities across the UK "risks doing untold damage to people's health and exacerbating the worst public health crisis of our lifetimes".
She told BBC Breakfast the mass migration of a million students could prompt a "silent avalanche of infections".
"There is far more of a risk than perhaps the general public has appreciated," she said, adding that universities were not prepared and risked becoming the "care homes of the second wave".
Ms Grady said Manchester would see 100,000 students arriving, Birmingham 80,000, and Leicester 40,000.
"These are all cities that have had some form of local lockdown and have come out of it or are about to go into one," she said.
And she warned the higher number of students expected at universities this year would make social distancing harder.
What's been the response?
Universities UK, which represents campus leaders, says many staff want to return to face-to-face teaching and research "where it is safe and appropriate to do so".
They are mindful of the benefits of in-person teaching and support for students' well-being and development, its president, Julia Buckingham, said.
The government says it is "confident that universities are well prepared for the return of students by taking measures such as introducing social distancing on campus, limiting travel requirement for classes and staggering teaching across extended days to reduce numbers on site".
It said guidance is "under constant review" to reflect the latest public health advice such as 2m distancing, or 1m plus with measures such as face coverings.
Professor Jonathan Ball, a virologist at the University of Nottingham, said universities were aware students returning to campus might be "a potential flair point for coronavirus infection" and were taking that risk "seriously".
He said universities would have their own rules and guidance, with sanctions "for students who willingly, knowingly break the rules of engagement".
But he cited veterinary students who had already returned to Nottingham, whom he praised for their "incredibly good" behaviour and attitude.
"We have to allow these students to get the education that they have worked hard for - and to enjoy university life as much as is possible at the moment," he told BBC News.
What are experts saying?
Prof Carl Heneghan, director of the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine at the University of Oxford, says it is safe for students to return to universities.
He told Breakfast that "right now it is as safe as it ever has been" to go back to campuses.
But he suggested universities could put back face-to-face teaching until the end of the academic year in spring or summer 2021, when the threat from coronavirus might have reduced.
"Can we do something over the summer, can we put a summer school on?" he asked, adding: "We need to maximise that [teaching] experience."
Second wave fears don't reflect how life has changed: Analysis by Nick Triggle, Health Correspondent
The language used by unions is very strong. There are plenty of infectious disease and public health experts who would not paint the threat in such extreme terms.
Whenever we hear about risks of a second wave or a sharp rise in cases we need to consider where we have come from.
The initial surge happened because the virus was spreading pretty much undetected for a period.
It was certainly more widespread than the UK and other countries realised in February and March.
By the time lockdown came there were an estimated 100,000 new infections a day in the UK.
Today we have over 1,000 confirmed infections a day, on average.
Of course some are going undetected, but it is clear the virus is currently under control.
As people circulate more - going back to work, schools and university - the likelihood is infections will rise.
But everyday life has completely transformed from what it was in February - there are many reasons why a second surge in infections like the first can, and should, be avoided.
What will university look like during coronavirus?
Students preparing for the new university term can expect changes on campuses - much like those that have affected other aspects of life since March.
Strict cleaning measures, lots of hand sanitiser, one-way systems and capacity limits for places such as the library and coffee shop will be common.
Close-knit seminars and office hours with lecturers are unlikely to take place face-to-face as they did before.
At the University of Leicester, students and staff will be screened for Covid-19 from October using a new form of mass testing developed by the institution's academics.
Vice-chancellor Prof Nishan Canagrarajah told the BBC Leicester would regularly test as many as 10,000 students and staff to monitor infections throughout the academic year, alongside NHS Test and Trace.
There will also be staggered arrival times to prevent all students returning to the city at once, he said.
Almost all institutions will be making greater use of online teaching methods for students studying non-practical subjects.
Aside from studies, Swansea University said plans to keep students safe included "bubbles" among flatmates, meaning a ban on parties or having people over to stay.
And nights out will look different, too. The University of Sheffield's student union has implemented an ordering app and table service, making its bars less crowded.
In Manchester, a student union is building outdoor "greenhouses" for drinkers to book in advance.
Nightclubs remain closed due to continued national restrictions.
Universities in the UK are being urged to scrap plans for face-to-face teaching until Christmas in order to prevent a second wave of coronavirus ... Earlier Posting by Hannah Richardson
Academics' union, UCU, said more than a million students moving around the country was "a recipe for disaster".
UCU leader Jo Grady said universities were not prepared and risked becoming the "care homes of the second wave".
But university bosses say they have worked hard to plan for a safe return to all aspects of student life.
The Department for Education said universities are well prepared and it is important to reopen education when it is safe to do so.
And Prof Carl Heneghan, director of the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine at the University of Oxford, told BBC Breakfast "right now it is as safe as it ever has been to go back" to campuses.
When students return in September, they will be expected to abide by new policies on the use of face coverings and social distancing protocols.
Meanwhile there will be safety partitions to keep them apart, as well as more cleaning and ventilation and smaller class sizes where face-to-face teaching takes place.
When national lockdown measures were brought in at the end of March, universities cancelled lectures, tutorials and some exams.
Many continued their lessons and lectures online however, and even held final exams remotely.
Over the summer, universities have been preparing for the return of their students with most promising a mix of face-to-face and online learning - or "blended learning" - with students taught in extended "bubble" groups.
Larissa Kennedy, the president of the National Union of Students, told Breakfast universities needed to "refrain from in-person teaching" unless it was absolutely necessary, for example, sessions in technical labs or studios.
"We need to ensure remote learning is as accessible as possible and I think we need to do that really quickly," she added.
Meanwhile few, if any, universities have taken the step of telling their students not to move into their accommodation.
Ms Grady said having tens of thousands of students heading into cities across the UK "risks doing untold damage to people's health and exacerbating the worst public health crisis of our lifetimes".
She told Breakfast the mass migration of a million students could prompt a "silent avalanche of infections".
"There is far more of a risk than perhaps the general public has appreciated," she said.
She said she was particularly worried about the risk of the virus spreading in cities with big student populations and in areas with fewer cases at present.
Ms Grady told the BBC: "If we look at some key cities: Manchester has 100,000 students; Birmingham isn't far behind with 80,000; and Leicester has 40,000.
"These are all cities that have had some form of local lockdown and have come out of it or are about to go into one."
"We are really worried about young people congregating in halls of residence and just what this will mean in terms of transmission," she added.
The already difficult situation, with universities doing their best to bring in socially distanced ways of working, has been made worse by the higher than expected number of students this year, she said.
Prof Heneghan suggested universities put back face-to-face teaching until the end of the academic year in spring or summer 2021, when the threat of the coronavirus may be reduced.
"Can we do something over the summer, can we put a summer school on?" he asked, adding: "We need to maximise that experience."
'No regular testing'
The exams crisis over the summer meant many more students ultimately achieved the grades needed to get into university, after the government's last-minute change of mind on school-assessed grades.
Universities UK president Julia Buckingham said: "Many staff want to return to in-person teaching, research and other activities where it is safe and appropriate to do so."
They are also mindful of the benefits of in-person teaching and support for students' well-being and development, she said.
"The dedication shown throughout the lockdown and into recovery has been remarkable," she added.
A Department for Education spokesman said: "We are confident that universities are well prepared for the return of students by taking measures such as introducing social distancing on campus, limiting travel requirement for classes and staggering teaching across extended days to reduce numbers on site.
"Opening universities is a part of the prime minister's cautious roadmap, and it is important that we continue to open education settings wherever it is safe to do so.
"We support face-to-face teaching only where possible and if safety guidelines are followed, but know that high-quality online teaching can also be delivered if necessary.
"We are keeping our guidance under constant review, and are currently updating our advice on reopening higher education buildings and campuses to reflect the latest public health advice, including on face coverings, local lockdowns and test and trace."